CVS Health (Aetna Inc.) vs Cigna Group

PUBLISHED Jul 2, 2024, 1:47:35 PM        SHARE

img
imgNoah Brody

Aetna Inc. vs Cigna Group

CVS Health (Aetna Inc.) vs The Cigna Group: Which Insurance Company is a Better Buy?

Aetna Inc. and The Cigna Group are two of the largest health insurance companies in the sector right now. In this article, we will be taking a look at what sets them apart from one another, and which is the better buy right now.

Aetna Inc. is an American health care company that offers and sells health care insurance. They are based out of Hartford, Connecticut, and are a subsidiary of CVS Health Corporation. Cigna Group is also a healthcare company based out of Connecticut, headquartered in Bloomfield. The two companies are tied together by more than just geography, however.

In the 1800s, Aetna separated their annuity company and fire insurance companies. The fire insurance company that left the Aetna name eventually became a part of the Connecticut General Life Insurance Company. This company ended up becoming one of the two companies that combined to form Cigna as it is known today.

Since the CVS Health acquisition of Aetna Inc. in 2018, the CVS Health Corporation is the stock symbol that would be relevant to the Aetna Insurance.

The Case for Cigna Group: Working Hard For Their Investors

Cigna has for some time been one of the largest players in the healthcare sector. In fact, Cigna is ranked as the 27th largest insurance company in America. Their current stock price of $330.90 comes after a tremendous year for their stock. In the last full year, Cigna’s stock has increased 23.64%. This, along with their historically strong dividend performance has led to them being a major player for many years now.

Speaking of their dividend, Cigna currently has quarterly dividends of $1.4, which is a 1.6% dividend yield. They have routinely increased their dividend payouts, but did have a small bump in the road in the early 2000s. They have aggressively worked to improve share price, including recently a $11.3 billion stock buyback.

In addition to their work to improve their stock price, based on the GuruFocus FCF intrinsic value calculator, Cigna is actually considerably undervalued. The intrinsic value of Cigna Group based on their free cash flow is $522.69, considerably higher the current trading price of $333.90.

Aetna

Is the Case for Aetna Inc. Stronger?

Aetna Inc. has been similarly successful to Cigna, though they are even larger in terms of their total health plan enrollment. In 2021, they were the 6th largest health insurance company in America. This success was reflected in the performance of their stock price leading to their acquisition by CVS Health Corporation.. Aetna Inc. was trading at $212.70, an all-time high for the company. Currently, CVS Health stock is trading at $60.99. This is an 11.18% decrease over the past full year.

The dividend performance for CVS Health is a lot stronger than the performance of their stock price. For the past 20 years, CVS has increased their dividend. Currently, the dividend yield stands at 4.35%, and quarterly dividends of $0.66. This is relatively strong, returning a far higher annual yield than Cigna.

The formula for intrinsic value for CVS indicates that similarly to Cigna, CVS Health stock may be undervalued. Currently based on that model, the intrinsic value of CVS stock is $146.56. This means the CVS Health stock is even more undervalued (based on this model) than that of Cigna Group!

Performance Comparison

Both Aetna Inc. and Cigna Group offer compelling reasons to consider them if you are looking into buying stock. While the stock performance of Cigna has been stronger recently, the CVS Health stock is also undervalued, and offers a stronger dividend yield. So how do we determine which is a better buy?

Trefis determines that while CVS has a higher P/S ratio, Cigna remains the stronger buy due to their greater return potential. Others point to the weaker stock performance of CVS Health, even with having greater revenue growth than Cigna as an indicator for potential future success. Both are valid strategies, and both stocks certainly have merit and have earned their consideration.

Over the past year, the debate of which is a better buy has heated up. While CVS Health’s stock has struggled, their revenue has steadily grown. However, when comparing to Cigna Group, especially in revenue per share, we can see that Cigna performs stronger there as well.

Conclusions

While both stocks warrant consideration from investors, I believe Cigna Group appears to be the stronger buy. While CVS Health operates one of the largest insurance companies in the world, and performs well by its own right, I believe it is not enough to match the opportunity of Cigna.

Cigna manages to maintain a stronger performance in terms of year-over-year revenue, despite CVS and Aetna increasing their revenue more last year. The difference in dividend yield could have been a deciding factor, if the recent performance for CVS gave me more optimism. While it is true they are undervalued, so is Cigna, who also has maintained strong stock performance and who have been active in increasing their stock price in recent years.

Aetna is one of the largest insurance companies in the world, and is only one component of what makes up CVS Health stock. I do believe that it does offer significant value to investors, and has maintained a strong dividend, but if I were able to choose only one, my choice would be Cigna Group.



Sound investments
don't happen alone

Find your crew, build teams, compete in VS MODE, and identify investment trends in our evergrowing investment ecosystem. You aren't on an island anymore, and our community is here to help you make informed decisions in a complex world.

More Reads
Expecting A Dip
Image

Stock Market Commentary

Differentiators
Image

How Stockbossup is different

If anyone listened they got a huge gain
Image

I have a post for 8/20/2022

Is Healthcare a Good Investment Right Now?
Image

Taking a deep dive into the healthcare sector to determine if it is a good time to buy!

Medtronic Vs Stryker: Which is a Better Buy?
Image

Which of these two major players in the medical device sector is a better buy?

What Materials Should I Invest in?
Image

The materials sector has a wide range of options for different investment strategies. From the speculative nature of rare earth elements to the income strategies around timber production, an investor looking through material stocks has a lot of directions to go.

What will the Metaverse be in five years?
Image

The metaverse is here to stay as the next iteration of the internet. While an older generation may not see why this is the next technology, a younger generation and their parents are seeing the transition.

Virtual Events in the Metaverse
Image

People are more than ever going to live events, but virtual events are seeing an uptick in 2024. With new ad revenue streams in works, virtual events could see a new resurgence.

Metaverse ETFs
Image

While the Metaverse megatrend is looking promising in 2024, the collapse in metaverse investments prices in 2021 and 2022 caused at least three metaverse themed ETFs to liquidate.

Microsoft and the Growth Explosion
Image

Microsoft is an amazing stock for new investors to try. The company has evolved, acquired, and developed a multifaceted set of businesses that are fundamentally driving growth. But for new investors, the barrier to entry is mindset.

AGCO Group - The Pure-Play Farming Stock May be too Hot!
Image

The stock’s intrinsic value clearly shows the cyclicality of the farming industry, independent of AGCO’s own analysis. Agco’s analysis also takes into account the farming industry cyclicality.

Littelfuse - Undervalued Opportunity to Hold for Years
Image

Littelfuse (LFUS) is a component manufacturer currently near a $6 Billion market capitalization. This makes it a small-cap stock, with the potential for further growth in its market segments or to be bought out by a competitor.

Dover Corporation - Great Dividend Stock but Possibly Overpriced
Image

Dover Corporation is a strong investment candidate thanks to its consistent dividend growth, its robust financial performance, and strong capital implementation plan. This stock fits into a strong dividend portfolio well that plans on holding onto stocks for multiple years.

Is BorgWarner a Buy?
Image

BorgWarner fell below $30 today, making it an interesting buy opportunity. The reasons are quite straightforward. The company’s book value per share is $25.36 a share. This means that as long as money continues to be made, BorgWarner becomes undervalued if it nears its book value per share.

Union Pacific is Going Nowhere
Image

Union Pacific is not a buy to start off 2024. Union Pacific is a fine business. There are issues but nothing that is significant enough to believe the company’s intrinsic value will shrink in the next decade.

Dividend Stock Watch List: Lanny’s February 2024 Edition
Image

Dividend investing happens, whether the stock market is up or down, whether the fed raises interest rates or lowers. Inflation or deflation. Banks are failing or being bailed out. Recession, no recession. It’s all about buying dividend income producing stocks – the best source of passive income source on your journey to financial freedom!

January 2024 Stock Considerations
Image

With a new trading year already in full swing it is time, once again, to highlight some of my potential stock purchases for the month.

5 Reasons Not to Use ChatGPT for Financial Advice
Image

It’s truly amazing how far AI has come in such a short period. Not only can it answer most questions, but it can also generate online posts, research papers, and even poetry. However, it still has its limitations.

The Zen Ten - My Top Picks for 2024
Image

I've managed to beat the market by an average of 3.7% per year over the past 10 years. Since I began using this list with clients in 2000, I’ve beaten the market by an average of 9.1% per year.

5 Key Benefits of Long Term Investing in Dividend Stocks
Image

Overall, long-term dividend investing in individual dividend stocks can be a reliable and potentially lucrative way to build wealth and generate passive income over the long term

Resources for Publishers
Resources for New Investors
Boosted with BossCoin
Financial Literacy Leaders
user_profile
Tom Hamilton
user_profile
Wise Intelligent
user_profile
Mark Robertson
user_profile
Kevin Matthews II
user_profile
Akeiva Ellis
user_profile
Brendan Dale
user_profile
Kenneth Chavis IV
user_profile
Sharita Humphrey